Edinburgh

Moderators: bill, Clive

Locked
FlyGLA
Posts: 195
Joined: Fri May 26, 2023 8:45 am

Re: Edinburgh

Post by FlyGLA »

GKirk wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 5:10 pm
Just don't read the Edinburgh thread if you dont like it. It's as simple as that. Jeezy peeps man
It's a Glasgow Airport Forum. If you want to discuss EDI then join an Edinburgh Airport forum or post on the many EDI-spam filled threads on Pprune or Airliners.net. Simple as that.

If I wanted to read the constant dribble from EDI-fanboys I'd go on Pprune but as someone who's sole interest in Scottish aviation is Glasgow Airport I'm not sure why myself and the other members who are only interested in GLA and GLA only should have to put up with the constant EDI boasting. As I said you don't see such activity on MAN, NCL, LPL or even PIK and ABZ threads. Only EDI. The famous Edinburgh obsession with Glasgow. The question is why we allow this to fester. Keep the EDI thread if people want to discuss EDI as an aside, but get rid of the EDI-fanboys.

If its so simple then answer me this Gkirk, there are members on this forum who only post about new routes on the EDI thread. You will not see them post negative news regarding EDI. You will not see them posting in any threads about GLA. They are only seen boasting about new routes from EDI or how every flight from EDI is always full. Why are these members here? Why would anyone join a Glasgow Airport Forum just to post about new routes at EDI? What was their motive for joining a Glasgow Airport Forum only to discuss EDI? It's the aviation equivalent of a Celtic fan joining a Rangers forum to boast about Celtic winning a treble. Anyone doing so would very quickly be banned and rightly so but seemingly, not here.

My issue isn't with the EDI thread as such. EDI can be a relevant discussion, as a side. My issue is it is blatantly being abused by EDI fanboys as a platform to boast and ill-wish upon GLA.
Clive wrote: Sat Jun 10, 2023 2:00 pm FlyGLA - as I say, I’ve been saying much of that for years. I wanted to get rid of the EDI thread because it’s nothing but hassle. When the mods act we are accused of being Nazi’s by people who then get banned for life so we moderate with a light hand. I held a poll to see what the consensus was on the EDI crap and the majority wanted to keep it. So it stayed, much to my chagrin

We’ll see what happens next.
Well no forum is a democracy. If you own and run the show, it's your money and time supporting the platform. If you want the EDI thread and the EDI fanboys gone ;)

Interesting that there was a vote, though. I guess the EDI fanboys voted in favour of keeping their willy-waving platform? I suggest you discount their votes and you might have a different picture although my stance is more keep the EDI thread if we must but, at least please get rid of the EDI fan boys who are only here to boast about new routes at EDI. They are a plague ruining what is actually a very good forum. Stevie Wonder could see their motives for joining a Glasgow Airport Forum.

Not one genuine GLA enthusiast would leave this site if you did close the EDI thread, not one. I suspect the only members who might have an issue with it are those who have an anterior motive and not so subtle agenda for being here.
viscount
Posts: 147
Joined: Sun Sep 26, 2021 11:12 am

Re: Edinburgh

Post by viscount »

I am now sorry I brought this point up. I am member of a few forums and I go to the relative forums for news about the airport concerned on their own forum
Unfortunately Gla has more pages on EDI than any other subject. If you want to discuss and complain about EDI set up a new forum and keep this one for news about Glasgow and Renfrewshire.
Having spent most of my working life at Glasgow airport, I am now retired living about 10 miles from EDI, and by the way I was born in Ayrshire so I am interested in news about all the airports also anything to do with Scottish aviation. But I wish you would post more about Gla and not PIK or Edi

Clive has spent a lot of time and money hosting this forum so you should all respect this.

Now let’s get on and post for Glasgow and stop complaining about EDI

Sent from my phone.
Iain
Posts: 305
Joined: Thu Dec 10, 2020 10:02 am

Re: Edinburgh

Post by Iain »

Sorry, but I don't think that anybody posting in this thread is an EDI "fanboy" - I'm certainly not one! :lol:

Whilst I'm happy to be proved wrong, I also don't get the impression that people posting in this thread are the same people that are posting fantasies in the pprune EDI thread.

Like it or not, EDI is one of GLA's two main rivals, so it's perfectly reasonable to talk about it imo, particularly in light of the relative performance of the two airports over the last decade or so.
Clive
Site Admin
Posts: 1486
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 8:59 pm

Re: Edinburgh

Post by Clive »

Iain wrote: Sun Jun 11, 2023 5:46 pm
Like it or not, EDI is one of GLA's two main rivals, so it's perfectly reasonable to talk about it imo, particularly in light of the relative performance of the two airports over the last decade or so.
Haven’t we done that one to death?
https://tinyurl.com/EGPFAmazon

Using this link cost nothing but your Amazon purchases can help me to fund the hosting of EGPF Forum and keep it free.
billyg6
Posts: 35
Joined: Tue May 05, 2020 8:17 pm

Re: Edinburgh

Post by billyg6 »

Iain wrote: Sun Jun 11, 2023 5:46 pm

Whilst I'm happy to be proved wrong, I also don't get the impression that people posting in this thread are the same people that are posting fantasies in the pprune EDI thread.

Planeenthusiast on here is planeraz on pprune ,he posts EDI stuff on there and on here at the same time , he also ridicules some who post on here to his buddies on pprune !
Clive
Site Admin
Posts: 1486
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 8:59 pm

Re: Edinburgh

Post by Clive »

This topic is now locked. Well done guys.
https://tinyurl.com/EGPFAmazon

Using this link cost nothing but your Amazon purchases can help me to fund the hosting of EGPF Forum and keep it free.
Clive
Site Admin
Posts: 1486
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 8:59 pm

Re: Edinburgh

Post by Clive »

Topic now unlocked. Hopefully one month was enough to concentrate minds.

As with all topics in this forum any kindergarten stuff will be deleted and the violators moderated.
https://tinyurl.com/EGPFAmazon

Using this link cost nothing but your Amazon purchases can help me to fund the hosting of EGPF Forum and keep it free.
Darren10
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2020 11:58 am

Re: Edinburgh

Post by Darren10 »

Just read a post on another rather popular airline forum claiming that there was some serious congestion issues at EDI today. 5 737s waiting on the taxiway for a stand at one point. One of Uniteds flights was also severely impacted waiting a reported 40 mins for a stand. As much as I applaud the meteoric rise of EDIs offerings, it also seems that the busy summer season has overtaken EDIs infrastructure and is now causing major issues.

I do wonder if the US Legacies in particular will be asking questions.
Clive
Site Admin
Posts: 1486
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 8:59 pm

Re: Edinburgh

Post by Clive »

Darren10 wrote: Sat Jul 15, 2023 3:21 pm Just read a post on another rather popular airline forum claiming that there was some serious congestion issues at EDI today. 5 737s waiting on the taxiway for a stand at one point. One of Uniteds flights was also severely impacted waiting a reported 40 mins for a stand. As much as I applaud the meteoric rise of EDIs offerings, it also seems that the busy summer season has overtaken EDIs infrastructure and is now causing major issues.

I do wonder if the US Legacies in particular will be asking questions.
GLA bosses will be using that as a selling point in negotiations. The hassle-free, more economic airport serving the same (ahem) market.
https://tinyurl.com/EGPFAmazon

Using this link cost nothing but your Amazon purchases can help me to fund the hosting of EGPF Forum and keep it free.
kenneth1
Posts: 24
Joined: Sat May 02, 2020 12:09 pm

Re: Edinburgh

Post by kenneth1 »

I completely agree, aircraft on the ground waiting for a stand do not make money for the airline and have disgruntled passengers on board. Additionally there is also this recurring problem there with the ground handlers inability to cope with passenger luggage. Surely these are issues that GLA could easily cope with and highlight to airlines.
Locked